[{"data":1,"prerenderedAt":-1},["ShallowReactive",2],{"cavaliers-14-2015-2016":3,"C5-legislature_annee-annees":91},[4,19,33,44,54,64,75],{"annee":5,"decision":6,"date":7,"url":8,"loi":9,"loi_url":10,"legislature":11,"articles":12,"total":18},"2015-2016","2015-723 DC","2015-12-17","http:\u002F\u002Fwww.conseil-constitutionnel.fr\u002Fdecision\u002F2015\u002F2015723DC.htm","LOI n° 2015-1702 du 21 décembre 2015 de financement de la sécurité sociale pour 2016","https:\u002F\u002Fwww.legifrance.gouv.fr\u002Fjorf\u002Fid\u002FJORFTEXT000031663208",14,{"cavalier_financier":13,"entonnoir":15},[14],"35",[16,17],"23","62",3,{"annee":5,"decision":20,"date":21,"url":22,"loi":23,"loi_url":24,"legislature":11,"articles":25,"total":32},"2015-726 DC","2015-12-29","http:\u002F\u002Fwww.conseil-constitutionnel.fr\u002Fdecision\u002F2015\u002F2015726DC.htm","LOI n° 2015-1786 du 29 décembre 2015 de finances rectificative pour 2015","https:\u002F\u002Fwww.legifrance.gouv.fr\u002Fjorf\u002Fid\u002FJORFTEXT000031733082",{"cavalier_financier":26,"entonnoir":30},[27,28,29],"43","100","115",[31],"50",4,{"annee":5,"decision":34,"date":35,"url":36,"loi":37,"loi_url":38,"legislature":11,"articles":39,"total":43},"2015-727 DC","2016-01-21","http:\u002F\u002Fwww.conseil-constitutionnel.fr\u002Fdecision\u002F2016\u002F2015727DC.htm","LOI n° 2016-41 du 26 janvier 2016 de modernisation de notre système de santé","https:\u002F\u002Fwww.legifrance.gouv.fr\u002Fjorf\u002Fid\u002FJORFTEXT000031912641",{"entonnoir":40},[41,42],"46","59",2,{"annee":5,"decision":45,"date":46,"url":47,"loi":48,"loi_url":49,"legislature":11,"articles":50,"total":53},"2016-728 DC","2016-03-03","http:\u002F\u002Fwww.conseil-constitutionnel.fr\u002Fdecision\u002F2016\u002F2016728DC.htm","LOI n° 2016-274 du 7 mars 2016 relative au droit des étrangers en France","https:\u002F\u002Fwww.legifrance.gouv.fr\u002Fjorf\u002Fid\u002FJORFTEXT000032164264",{"entonnoir":51},[52],"20",1,{"annee":5,"decision":55,"date":56,"url":57,"loi":58,"loi_url":59,"legislature":11,"articles":60,"total":43},"2016-732 DC","2016-07-28","http:\u002F\u002Fwww.conseil-constitutionnel.fr\u002Fdecision\u002F2016\u002F2016732DC.htm","LOI organique n° 2016-1090 du 8 août 2016 relative aux garanties statutaires, aux obligations déontologiques et au recrutement des magistrats ainsi qu'au Conseil supérieur de la magistrature","https:\u002F\u002Fwww.legifrance.gouv.fr\u002Fjorf\u002Fid\u002FJORFTEXT000033011065",{"cavalier":61},[62,63],"48","49",{"annee":5,"decision":65,"date":66,"url":67,"loi":68,"loi_url":69,"legislature":11,"articles":70,"total":18},"2016-736 DC","2016-08-04","http:\u002F\u002Fwww.conseil-constitutionnel.fr\u002Fdecision\u002F2016\u002F2016736DC.htm","LOI n° 2016-1088 du 8 août 2016 relative au travail, à la modernisation du dialogue social et à la sécurisation des parcours professionnels","https:\u002F\u002Fwww.legifrance.gouv.fr\u002Fjorf\u002Fid\u002FJORFTEXT000032983213",{"cavalier":71,"entonnoir":73},[17,72],"65",[74],"39",{"annee":5,"decision":76,"date":66,"url":77,"loi":78,"loi_url":79,"legislature":11,"articles":80,"total":90},"2016-737 DC","http:\u002F\u002Fwww.conseil-constitutionnel.fr\u002Fdecision\u002F2016\u002F2016737DC.htm","LOI n° 2016-1087 du 8 août 2016 pour la reconquête de la biodiversité, de la nature et des paysages","https:\u002F\u002Fwww.legifrance.gouv.fr\u002Fjorf\u002Fid\u002FJORFTEXT000033016237",{"cavalier":81,"entonnoir":87},[82,83,84,85,86],"76","77","78","79","138",[88,89],"24","29",7,{"definition":92,"lot":98,"date_calcul":99,"collectes":100,"valeurs":171},{"code":93,"version":53,"date":94,"intitule":95,"texte_methode":96,"reference_journal":97},"C5","2026-11-14","Articles censurés parce qu'ils n'avaient pas leur place dans la loi","Nombre d'articles de la loi déférée déclarés contraires à la Constitution, au dispositif d'une décision DC sur une loi ordinaire ou organique, parce qu'ils n'avaient pas leur place dans la loi ou y avaient été introduits trop tard : total des trois catégories, puis cavaliers législatifs (pas de lien, même indirect, avec le texte : article 45, alinéa 1, de la Constitution), cavaliers financiers ou sociaux (étrangers au domaine des lois de finances ou de financement de la sécurité sociale) et règle de l'entonnoir (ajout après la première lecture sans relation directe avec une disposition restant en discussion). Unité : l'article (décision, article) ; un article relevé dans deux catégories compte une fois dans le total. Part des lois déférées avec au moins un tel article, avec effectifs et marge à 95 % (Wilson). Décisions depuis le 1er janvier 2010, rattachées à la période de leur date (législatures 13 à 17, années parlementaires). Indicateur de qualité de la procédure législative, hors de l'hypothèse H.","Définitions du jalon 2 v0.6 (§ 4, 7, 8) ; cadrage §9, 08\u002F11 et 11\u002F11\u002F2026","b6389e77-cc8b-41ae-9fc1-1a9d89031ccb","2026-11-22T04:57:26.884Z",[101,107,112,118,124,130,135,139,145,150,154,160,165],{"source":102,"nom_fichier":103,"date_collecte":104,"md5_calcule":105,"url":106},"LEGIFRANCE","api-legifrance","2026-11-22T04:55:29.122Z","","https:\u002F\u002Fapi.piste.gouv.fr\u002Fdila\u002Flegifrance\u002Flf-engine-app",{"source":108,"nom_fichier":109,"date_collecte":110,"md5_calcule":105,"url":111},"CC_DECISIONS","decisions","2026-11-22T04:55:29.094Z","https:\u002F\u002Fwww.conseil-constitutionnel.fr\u002Fsitemap.xml",{"source":113,"nom_fichier":114,"date_collecte":115,"md5_calcule":116,"url":117},"SENAT_PROMULGUEES","promulguees.csv","2026-11-22T04:55:10.733Z","ac9453bfb9b68ef58b9443c8e995247b","https:\u002F\u002Fdata.senat.fr\u002Fdata\u002Fdosleg\u002Fpromulguees.csv",{"source":119,"nom_fichier":120,"date_collecte":121,"md5_calcule":122,"url":123},"AN_ACTEURS","AMO30_tous_acteurs_tous_mandats_tous_organes_historique.json.zip","2026-11-22T04:40:04.350Z","59907e737a0fb7b270fd54d199689b95","https:\u002F\u002Fdata.assemblee-nationale.fr\u002Fstatic\u002FopenData\u002Frepository\u002F17\u002Famo\u002Ftous_acteurs_mandats_organes_xi_legislature\u002FAMO30_tous_acteurs_tous_mandats_tous_organes_historique.json.zip",{"source":125,"nom_fichier":126,"date_collecte":127,"md5_calcule":128,"url":129},"AN_SCRUTINS","Scrutins_XV.json.zip","2026-11-22T04:39:56.748Z","df161de32586f3de9684bd0c0ebf6a40","https:\u002F\u002Fdata.assemblee-nationale.fr\u002Fstatic\u002FopenData\u002Frepository\u002F15\u002Floi\u002Fscrutins\u002FScrutins_XV.json.zip",{"source":125,"nom_fichier":131,"date_collecte":132,"md5_calcule":133,"url":134},"Scrutins.json.zip","2026-11-22T04:39:56.446Z","fd88a684d8eeca8725c469aa332a7b3e","https:\u002F\u002Fdata.assemblee-nationale.fr\u002Fstatic\u002FopenData\u002Frepository\u002F16\u002Floi\u002Fscrutins\u002FScrutins.json.zip",{"source":125,"nom_fichier":131,"date_collecte":136,"md5_calcule":137,"url":138},"2026-11-22T04:39:50.592Z","f1518720f3550cfe43bd62c78c03de94","https:\u002F\u002Fdata.assemblee-nationale.fr\u002Fstatic\u002FopenData\u002Frepository\u002F17\u002Floi\u002Fscrutins\u002FScrutins.json.zip",{"source":140,"nom_fichier":141,"date_collecte":142,"md5_calcule":143,"url":144},"AN_DOSSIERS","Dossiers_Legislatifs_XV.json.zip","2026-11-22T04:39:49.852Z","08f79aa683f73dbfe43b96c3eff0a64d","https:\u002F\u002Fdata.assemblee-nationale.fr\u002Fstatic\u002FopenData\u002Frepository\u002F15\u002Floi\u002Fdossiers_legislatifs\u002FDossiers_Legislatifs_XV.json.zip",{"source":140,"nom_fichier":146,"date_collecte":147,"md5_calcule":148,"url":149},"Dossiers_Legislatifs.json.zip","2026-11-22T04:39:49.314Z","e7eb837f9ff3128e3dcbcdeddf6a12d4","https:\u002F\u002Fdata.assemblee-nationale.fr\u002Fstatic\u002FopenData\u002Frepository\u002F16\u002Floi\u002Fdossiers_legislatifs\u002FDossiers_Legislatifs.json.zip",{"source":140,"nom_fichier":146,"date_collecte":151,"md5_calcule":152,"url":153},"2026-11-21T11:46:47.742Z","55a69fc0d8eac47805d8f94f6bec6bc5","https:\u002F\u002Fdata.assemblee-nationale.fr\u002Fstatic\u002FopenData\u002Frepository\u002F17\u002Floi\u002Fdossiers_legislatifs\u002FDossiers_Legislatifs.json.zip",{"source":155,"nom_fichier":156,"date_collecte":157,"md5_calcule":158,"url":159},"DOLE","DOLE_20261120-222218.tar.gz","2026-11-21T04:51:40.647Z","50dc4cc33b7e6cebd1c5a889984210da","https:\u002F\u002Fechanges.dila.gouv.fr\u002FOPENDATA\u002FDOLE\u002FDOLE_20261120-222218.tar.gz",{"source":161,"nom_fichier":162,"date_collecte":163,"md5_calcule":105,"url":164},"CC_TABLES","actualite","2026-11-14T04:52:51.930Z","https:\u002F\u002Fwww.conseil-constitutionnel.fr\u002Factualites\u002Ftables-analytiques-des-decisions-du-conseil-constitutionnel-actualisees-au-31-decembre-2024",{"source":166,"nom_fichier":167,"date_collecte":168,"md5_calcule":169,"url":170},"CONSTIT","Freemium_constit_global_20261108-140000.tar.gz","2026-11-10T04:37:49.402Z","21844ec0786bfb02c6417167eb647e9d","https:\u002F\u002Fechanges.dila.gouv.fr\u002FOPENDATA\u002FCONSTIT\u002FFreemium_constit_global_20261108-140000.tar.gz",[172,179,183,187,190,194,198,202,204,208,211,213,215,219,221,223,226,228,230,234],{"periode_type":173,"periode":174,"ventilation":175,"valeur":176,"numerateur":11,"denominateur":177,"serie":105,"borne_basse":177,"borne_haute":177,"incomplet":178},"legislature_annee","13\u002F2009-2010","lois_deferees","14.0000",null,false,{"periode_type":173,"periode":180,"ventilation":175,"valeur":181,"numerateur":182,"denominateur":177,"serie":105,"borne_basse":177,"borne_haute":177,"incomplet":178},"13\u002F2010-2011","27.0000",27,{"periode_type":173,"periode":184,"ventilation":175,"valeur":185,"numerateur":186,"denominateur":177,"serie":105,"borne_basse":177,"borne_haute":177,"incomplet":178},"13\u002F2011-2012","11.0000",11,{"periode_type":173,"periode":188,"ventilation":175,"valeur":189,"numerateur":53,"denominateur":177,"serie":105,"borne_basse":177,"borne_haute":177,"incomplet":178},"14\u002F2011-2012","1.0000",{"periode_type":173,"periode":191,"ventilation":175,"valeur":192,"numerateur":193,"denominateur":177,"serie":105,"borne_basse":177,"borne_haute":177,"incomplet":178},"14\u002F2012-2013","19.0000",19,{"periode_type":173,"periode":195,"ventilation":175,"valeur":196,"numerateur":197,"denominateur":177,"serie":105,"borne_basse":177,"borne_haute":177,"incomplet":178},"14\u002F2013-2014","26.0000",26,{"periode_type":173,"periode":199,"ventilation":175,"valeur":200,"numerateur":201,"denominateur":177,"serie":105,"borne_basse":177,"borne_haute":177,"incomplet":178},"14\u002F2014-2015","17.0000",17,{"periode_type":173,"periode":203,"ventilation":175,"valeur":200,"numerateur":201,"denominateur":177,"serie":105,"borne_basse":177,"borne_haute":177,"incomplet":178},"14\u002F2015-2016",{"periode_type":173,"periode":205,"ventilation":175,"valeur":206,"numerateur":207,"denominateur":177,"serie":105,"borne_basse":177,"borne_haute":177,"incomplet":178},"14\u002F2016-2017","12.0000",12,{"periode_type":173,"periode":209,"ventilation":175,"valeur":210,"numerateur":18,"denominateur":177,"serie":105,"borne_basse":177,"borne_haute":177,"incomplet":178},"15\u002F2016-2017","3.0000",{"periode_type":173,"periode":212,"ventilation":175,"valeur":176,"numerateur":11,"denominateur":177,"serie":105,"borne_basse":177,"borne_haute":177,"incomplet":178},"15\u002F2017-2018",{"periode_type":173,"periode":214,"ventilation":175,"valeur":200,"numerateur":201,"denominateur":177,"serie":105,"borne_basse":177,"borne_haute":177,"incomplet":178},"15\u002F2018-2019",{"periode_type":173,"periode":216,"ventilation":175,"valeur":217,"numerateur":218,"denominateur":177,"serie":105,"borne_basse":177,"borne_haute":177,"incomplet":178},"15\u002F2019-2020","16.0000",16,{"periode_type":173,"periode":220,"ventilation":175,"valeur":200,"numerateur":201,"denominateur":177,"serie":105,"borne_basse":177,"borne_haute":177,"incomplet":178},"15\u002F2020-2021",{"periode_type":173,"periode":222,"ventilation":175,"valeur":176,"numerateur":11,"denominateur":177,"serie":105,"borne_basse":177,"borne_haute":177,"incomplet":178},"15\u002F2021-2022",{"periode_type":173,"periode":224,"ventilation":175,"valeur":225,"numerateur":32,"denominateur":177,"serie":105,"borne_basse":177,"borne_haute":177,"incomplet":178},"16\u002F2021-2022","4.0000",{"periode_type":173,"periode":227,"ventilation":175,"valeur":185,"numerateur":186,"denominateur":177,"serie":105,"borne_basse":177,"borne_haute":177,"incomplet":178},"16\u002F2022-2023",{"periode_type":173,"periode":229,"ventilation":175,"valeur":176,"numerateur":11,"denominateur":177,"serie":105,"borne_basse":177,"borne_haute":177,"incomplet":178},"16\u002F2023-2024",{"periode_type":173,"periode":231,"ventilation":175,"valeur":232,"numerateur":233,"denominateur":177,"serie":105,"borne_basse":177,"borne_haute":177,"incomplet":178},"17\u002F2024-2025","21.0000",21,{"periode_type":173,"periode":235,"ventilation":175,"valeur":236,"numerateur":237,"denominateur":177,"serie":105,"borne_basse":177,"borne_haute":177,"incomplet":178},"17\u002F2025-2026","20.0000",20]