{"definition": {"code": "C3b", "version": 1, "date": "2026-11-14", "intitule": "Lois censur\u00e9es en QPC sans contr\u00f4le pr\u00e9alable", "texte_methode": "Parmi les lois dont au moins une disposition a \u00e9t\u00e9 d\u00e9clar\u00e9e contraire \u00e0 la Constitution au fond en QPC, part de celles qui n'avaient jamais \u00e9t\u00e9 d\u00e9f\u00e9r\u00e9es au Conseil avant leur promulgation (CONSTIT depuis 1959 et liste des lois promulgu\u00e9es du S\u00e9nat), par \u00e9poque de la loi (avant 1959, 1959 \u2013 29 octobre 1974, 1974-2009, depuis 2010) et pour l'ensemble. Cat\u00e9gories : jamais d\u00e9f\u00e9r\u00e9e ; d\u00e9f\u00e9r\u00e9e, disposition non examin\u00e9e ; d\u00e9f\u00e9r\u00e9e, puis censur\u00e9e apr\u00e8s un changement des circonstances constat\u00e9 par la d\u00e9cision. Loi d'origine : loi cit\u00e9e par la d\u00e9cision (ratio principal), et en seconde s\u00e9rie avec les rattachements probables par l'historique des articles (L\u00e9gifrance). Les QPC qui portent seulement sur une ordonnance sont compt\u00e9es \u00e0 part, comme celles dont aucune loi n'est rattach\u00e9e. Effectifs et marge \u00e0 95 % (Wilson).", "reference_journal": "D\u00e9finitions du jalon 2 v0.6 (\u00a7 3, 7, 8) ; cadrage \u00a79, 09/11, 10/11, 11/11 et 14/11/2026"}, "lot": "b6389e77-cc8b-41ae-9fc1-1a9d89031ccb", "date_calcul": "2026-11-22T04:57:26.884Z", "collectes": [{"source": "LEGIFRANCE", "nom_fichier": "api-legifrance", "date_collecte": "2026-11-22T04:55:29.122Z", "md5_calcule": "", "url": "https://api.piste.gouv.fr/dila/legifrance/lf-engine-app"}, {"source": "CC_DECISIONS", "nom_fichier": "decisions", "date_collecte": "2026-11-22T04:55:29.094Z", "md5_calcule": "", "url": "https://www.conseil-constitutionnel.fr/sitemap.xml"}, {"source": "SENAT_PROMULGUEES", "nom_fichier": "promulguees.csv", "date_collecte": "2026-11-22T04:55:10.733Z", "md5_calcule": "ac9453bfb9b68ef58b9443c8e995247b", "url": "https://data.senat.fr/data/dosleg/promulguees.csv"}, {"source": "AN_ACTEURS", "nom_fichier": "AMO30_tous_acteurs_tous_mandats_tous_organes_historique.json.zip", "date_collecte": "2026-11-22T04:40:04.350Z", "md5_calcule": "59907e737a0fb7b270fd54d199689b95", "url": "https://data.assemblee-nationale.fr/static/openData/repository/17/amo/tous_acteurs_mandats_organes_xi_legislature/AMO30_tous_acteurs_tous_mandats_tous_organes_historique.json.zip"}, {"source": "AN_SCRUTINS", "nom_fichier": "Scrutins_XV.json.zip", "date_collecte": "2026-11-22T04:39:56.748Z", "md5_calcule": "df161de32586f3de9684bd0c0ebf6a40", "url": "https://data.assemblee-nationale.fr/static/openData/repository/15/loi/scrutins/Scrutins_XV.json.zip"}, {"source": "AN_SCRUTINS", "nom_fichier": "Scrutins.json.zip", "date_collecte": "2026-11-22T04:39:56.446Z", "md5_calcule": "fd88a684d8eeca8725c469aa332a7b3e", "url": "https://data.assemblee-nationale.fr/static/openData/repository/16/loi/scrutins/Scrutins.json.zip"}, {"source": "AN_SCRUTINS", "nom_fichier": "Scrutins.json.zip", "date_collecte": "2026-11-22T04:39:50.592Z", "md5_calcule": "f1518720f3550cfe43bd62c78c03de94", "url": "https://data.assemblee-nationale.fr/static/openData/repository/17/loi/scrutins/Scrutins.json.zip"}, {"source": "AN_DOSSIERS", "nom_fichier": "Dossiers_Legislatifs_XV.json.zip", "date_collecte": "2026-11-22T04:39:49.852Z", "md5_calcule": "08f79aa683f73dbfe43b96c3eff0a64d", "url": "https://data.assemblee-nationale.fr/static/openData/repository/15/loi/dossiers_legislatifs/Dossiers_Legislatifs_XV.json.zip"}, {"source": "AN_DOSSIERS", "nom_fichier": "Dossiers_Legislatifs.json.zip", "date_collecte": "2026-11-22T04:39:49.314Z", "md5_calcule": "e7eb837f9ff3128e3dcbcdeddf6a12d4", "url": "https://data.assemblee-nationale.fr/static/openData/repository/16/loi/dossiers_legislatifs/Dossiers_Legislatifs.json.zip"}, {"source": "AN_DOSSIERS", "nom_fichier": "Dossiers_Legislatifs.json.zip", "date_collecte": "2026-11-21T11:46:47.742Z", "md5_calcule": "55a69fc0d8eac47805d8f94f6bec6bc5", "url": "https://data.assemblee-nationale.fr/static/openData/repository/17/loi/dossiers_legislatifs/Dossiers_Legislatifs.json.zip"}, {"source": "DOLE", "nom_fichier": "DOLE_20261120-222218.tar.gz", "date_collecte": "2026-11-21T04:51:40.647Z", "md5_calcule": "50dc4cc33b7e6cebd1c5a889984210da", "url": "https://echanges.dila.gouv.fr/OPENDATA/DOLE/DOLE_20261120-222218.tar.gz"}, {"source": "CC_TABLES", "nom_fichier": "actualite", "date_collecte": "2026-11-14T04:52:51.930Z", "md5_calcule": "", "url": "https://www.conseil-constitutionnel.fr/actualites/tables-analytiques-des-decisions-du-conseil-constitutionnel-actualisees-au-31-decembre-2024"}, {"source": "CONSTIT", "nom_fichier": "Freemium_constit_global_20261108-140000.tar.gz", "date_collecte": "2026-11-10T04:37:49.402Z", "md5_calcule": "21844ec0786bfb02c6417167eb647e9d", "url": "https://echanges.dila.gouv.fr/OPENDATA/CONSTIT/Freemium_constit_global_20261108-140000.tar.gz"}], "valeurs": [{"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "1959_1974", "ventilation": "deferees_changement_circonstances", "valeur": "0.0000", "numerateur": 0, "denominateur": null, "serie": "avec_rattachements_probables", "borne_basse": null, "borne_haute": null, "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "1959_1974", "ventilation": "deferees_changement_circonstances", "valeur": "0.0000", "numerateur": 0, "denominateur": null, "serie": "decision_cite_loi", "borne_basse": null, "borne_haute": null, "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "1959_1974", "ventilation": "deferees_non_examinee", "valeur": "0.0000", "numerateur": 0, "denominateur": null, "serie": "avec_rattachements_probables", "borne_basse": null, "borne_haute": null, "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "1959_1974", "ventilation": "deferees_non_examinee", "valeur": "0.0000", "numerateur": 0, "denominateur": null, "serie": "decision_cite_loi", "borne_basse": null, "borne_haute": null, "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "1959_1974", "ventilation": "jamais_deferees", "valeur": "1.0000", "numerateur": 7, "denominateur": 7, "serie": "avec_rattachements_probables", "borne_basse": "0.6457", "borne_haute": "1.0000", "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "1959_1974", "ventilation": "jamais_deferees", "valeur": "1.0000", "numerateur": 7, "denominateur": 7, "serie": "decision_cite_loi", "borne_basse": "0.6457", "borne_haute": "1.0000", "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "1959_1974", "ventilation": "lois_censurees", "valeur": "7.0000", "numerateur": 7, "denominateur": null, "serie": "avec_rattachements_probables", "borne_basse": null, "borne_haute": null, "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "1959_1974", "ventilation": "lois_censurees", "valeur": "7.0000", "numerateur": 7, "denominateur": null, "serie": "decision_cite_loi", "borne_basse": null, "borne_haute": null, "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "1974_2009", "ventilation": "deferees_changement_circonstances", "valeur": "2.0000", "numerateur": 2, "denominateur": null, "serie": "decision_cite_loi", "borne_basse": null, "borne_haute": null, "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "1974_2009", "ventilation": "deferees_changement_circonstances", "valeur": "2.0000", "numerateur": 2, "denominateur": null, "serie": "avec_rattachements_probables", "borne_basse": null, "borne_haute": null, "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "1974_2009", "ventilation": "deferees_non_examinee", "valeur": "23.0000", "numerateur": 23, "denominateur": null, "serie": "avec_rattachements_probables", "borne_basse": null, "borne_haute": null, "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "1974_2009", "ventilation": "deferees_non_examinee", "valeur": "15.0000", "numerateur": 15, "denominateur": null, "serie": "decision_cite_loi", "borne_basse": null, "borne_haute": null, "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "1974_2009", "ventilation": "jamais_deferees", "valeur": "0.6304", "numerateur": 29, "denominateur": 46, "serie": "decision_cite_loi", "borne_basse": "0.4860", "borne_haute": "0.7548", "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "1974_2009", "ventilation": "jamais_deferees", "valeur": "0.6212", "numerateur": 41, "denominateur": 66, "serie": "avec_rattachements_probables", "borne_basse": "0.5006", "borne_haute": "0.7285", "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "1974_2009", "ventilation": "lois_censurees", "valeur": "46.0000", "numerateur": 46, "denominateur": null, "serie": "decision_cite_loi", "borne_basse": null, "borne_haute": null, "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "1974_2009", "ventilation": "lois_censurees", "valeur": "66.0000", "numerateur": 66, "denominateur": null, "serie": "avec_rattachements_probables", "borne_basse": null, "borne_haute": null, "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "avant_1959", "ventilation": "deferees_changement_circonstances", "valeur": "0.0000", "numerateur": 0, "denominateur": null, "serie": "decision_cite_loi", "borne_basse": null, "borne_haute": null, "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "avant_1959", "ventilation": "deferees_changement_circonstances", "valeur": "0.0000", "numerateur": 0, "denominateur": null, "serie": "avec_rattachements_probables", "borne_basse": null, "borne_haute": null, "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "avant_1959", "ventilation": "deferees_non_examinee", "valeur": "0.0000", "numerateur": 0, "denominateur": null, "serie": "decision_cite_loi", "borne_basse": null, "borne_haute": null, "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "avant_1959", "ventilation": "deferees_non_examinee", "valeur": "0.0000", "numerateur": 0, "denominateur": null, "serie": "avec_rattachements_probables", "borne_basse": null, "borne_haute": null, "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "avant_1959", "ventilation": "jamais_deferees", "valeur": "1.0000", "numerateur": 11, "denominateur": 11, "serie": "decision_cite_loi", "borne_basse": "0.7412", "borne_haute": "1.0000", "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "avant_1959", "ventilation": "jamais_deferees", "valeur": "1.0000", "numerateur": 11, "denominateur": 11, "serie": "avec_rattachements_probables", "borne_basse": "0.7412", "borne_haute": "1.0000", "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "avant_1959", "ventilation": "lois_censurees", "valeur": "11.0000", "numerateur": 11, "denominateur": null, "serie": "decision_cite_loi", "borne_basse": null, "borne_haute": null, "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "avant_1959", "ventilation": "lois_censurees", "valeur": "11.0000", "numerateur": 11, "denominateur": null, "serie": "avec_rattachements_probables", "borne_basse": null, "borne_haute": null, "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "depuis_2010", "ventilation": "deferees_changement_circonstances", "valeur": "3.0000", "numerateur": 3, "denominateur": null, "serie": "avec_rattachements_probables", "borne_basse": null, "borne_haute": null, "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "depuis_2010", "ventilation": "deferees_changement_circonstances", "valeur": "3.0000", "numerateur": 3, "denominateur": null, "serie": "decision_cite_loi", "borne_basse": null, "borne_haute": null, "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "depuis_2010", "ventilation": "deferees_non_examinee", "valeur": "56.0000", "numerateur": 56, "denominateur": null, "serie": "decision_cite_loi", "borne_basse": null, "borne_haute": null, "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "depuis_2010", "ventilation": "deferees_non_examinee", "valeur": "61.0000", "numerateur": 61, "denominateur": null, "serie": "avec_rattachements_probables", "borne_basse": null, "borne_haute": null, "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "depuis_2010", "ventilation": "jamais_deferees", "valeur": "0.4182", "numerateur": 46, "denominateur": 110, "serie": "avec_rattachements_probables", "borne_basse": "0.3303", "borne_haute": "0.5116", "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "depuis_2010", "ventilation": "jamais_deferees", "valeur": "0.3918", "numerateur": 38, "denominateur": 97, "serie": "decision_cite_loi", "borne_basse": "0.3005", "borne_haute": "0.4912", "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "depuis_2010", "ventilation": "lois_censurees", "valeur": "97.0000", "numerateur": 97, "denominateur": null, "serie": "decision_cite_loi", "borne_basse": null, "borne_haute": null, "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "depuis_2010", "ventilation": "lois_censurees", "valeur": "110.0000", "numerateur": 110, "denominateur": null, "serie": "avec_rattachements_probables", "borne_basse": null, "borne_haute": null, "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "ensemble", "ventilation": "deferees_changement_circonstances", "valeur": "5.0000", "numerateur": 5, "denominateur": null, "serie": "avec_rattachements_probables", "borne_basse": null, "borne_haute": null, "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "ensemble", "ventilation": "deferees_changement_circonstances", "valeur": "5.0000", "numerateur": 5, "denominateur": null, "serie": "decision_cite_loi", "borne_basse": null, "borne_haute": null, "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "ensemble", "ventilation": "deferees_non_examinee", "valeur": "71.0000", "numerateur": 71, "denominateur": null, "serie": "decision_cite_loi", "borne_basse": null, "borne_haute": null, "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "ensemble", "ventilation": "deferees_non_examinee", "valeur": "84.0000", "numerateur": 84, "denominateur": null, "serie": "avec_rattachements_probables", "borne_basse": null, "borne_haute": null, "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "ensemble", "ventilation": "jamais_deferees", "valeur": "0.5280", "numerateur": 85, "denominateur": 161, "serie": "decision_cite_loi", "borne_basse": "0.4511", "borne_haute": "0.6035", "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "ensemble", "ventilation": "jamais_deferees", "valeur": "0.5412", "numerateur": 105, "denominateur": 194, "serie": "avec_rattachements_probables", "borne_basse": "0.4710", "borne_haute": "0.6099", "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "ensemble", "ventilation": "lois_censurees", "valeur": "161.0000", "numerateur": 161, "denominateur": null, "serie": "decision_cite_loi", "borne_basse": null, "borne_haute": null, "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "ensemble", "ventilation": "lois_censurees", "valeur": "194.0000", "numerateur": 194, "denominateur": null, "serie": "avec_rattachements_probables", "borne_basse": null, "borne_haute": null, "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "ensemble", "ventilation": "qpc_ordonnance", "valeur": "50.0000", "numerateur": 50, "denominateur": null, "serie": "decision_cite_loi", "borne_basse": null, "borne_haute": null, "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "ensemble", "ventilation": "qpc_ordonnance", "valeur": "43.0000", "numerateur": 43, "denominateur": null, "serie": "avec_rattachements_probables", "borne_basse": null, "borne_haute": null, "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "ensemble", "ventilation": "qpc_sans_loi", "valeur": "77.0000", "numerateur": 77, "denominateur": null, "serie": "decision_cite_loi", "borne_basse": null, "borne_haute": null, "incomplet": false}, {"periode_type": "epoque_loi", "periode": "ensemble", "ventilation": "qpc_sans_loi", "valeur": "13.0000", "numerateur": 13, "denominateur": null, "serie": "avec_rattachements_probables", "borne_basse": null, "borne_haute": null, "incomplet": false}]}